N461WN

1.1 HISTORY OF FLIGHT

On August 19, 2004, about 1455 Pacific daylight time, an Asiana Airlines Boeing 747-400, HI7415, overflew a Southwest Airlines Boeing 737-7H4, N461WN, while the Southwest airplane was in position on the active runway 24L, at Los Angeles International Airport, Los Angeles, California. Southwest Airlines operated the Boeing 737 under the provisions of 14 CFR Part 121, and Asiana Airlines operated the Boeing 747 under the provisions of 14 CFR Part 129. There was no damage to either airplane nor injuries to the combined total of 417 passengers and 29 crewmembers. Visual meteorological conditions prevailed and an instrument flight plan had been filed.

On August 24th Southwest Airlines safety personnel reported to the National Transportation Safety Board investigator that the captain of Southwest flight 440 (SWA440) reported that an Asiana Boeing 747 (AAR204) came with in 200 feet of his airplane while it was executing a go-around on runway 24L. Southwest flight 440 had been cleared for takeoff on runway 24L. The captain stated that he became concerned when the Asiana airplane did not come in to his view, as it should have, when landing on the parallel runway 24R. He began to move his airplane off the runway when the Asiana airplane overflew his, coming within 200 feet. The captain of AAR204 stated that he and his copilot identified the runway conflict while they were on the short final approach for landing and executed a go-around about 400 feet above ground level (agl).

At 2151:21, the LAX local 2 (LC2) tower controller cleared AAR204 to land on runway 24L, and the flight crew acknowledged the landing clearance. AAR204 was conducting an ILS runway 24L approach and radar data indicated the aircraft was 9.3 miles east of the airport. About this time, the LAX operations supervisor on duty asked the local assist 1 (LA1) controller (hereafter referred to as the "LC2 relief controller") to relieve the LC2 controller, who needed a break.

At 2153:08, the LC2 controller began a position relief briefing for the LC2 relief controller. He stated, "Alright uh both runways available. Let's see you got the board you said. Got a lot of flow up there, a lot of flow. Better study up on that." The LC2 relief controller stated, "uh huh, I do I came from assist one." The LC2 controller continued, "Alright. They're on the boards, the inboards I should say, both runways available, PIREPs none, you can visual out. Uh, rolling out on the right is Southwest, cleared to land is Asiana on the left. Southwest on the pad is a LAXX I haven't tried to coordinate. You got a King Air, I'm sorry, he just left, so right now you're back to released. These two have been approved, but not run down or released…" The LC2 controller continued, "This one is awaiting approval," then stated, "and that's all I can think of." At 2153:43, the LC2 relief controller advised, "Alright well I've got it." The LC2 controller responded by saying, "Uh helicopters I'm sorry you have one more." The LC2 relief controller asked, "Oh and who is it?" As the LC2 controller began to say the helicopter's call sign, "Coast Guard six five...," he was interrupted by a transmission from a Southwest Airlines flight crew who had just landed runway 24R and requested permission to exit the runway at a different location than instructed. The LC2 controller approved the request, and after he received an acknowledgement from the Southwest crew, he continued briefing the LC2 relief controller.

At 2153:55, the LC2 controller completed the briefing by informing the LC2 relief controller of the Coast Guard helicopter's call sign and location on the airport, and that no other helicopters were operating in the vicinity of the airport. During the interview, the LC2 controller stated that at this time he unplugged his headset from the position and left to speak briefly with the supervisor about his break.

At 2154:06, the LC2 relief controller issued his first radio communication from the LC2 position, "Southwest four forty runway two four left position and hold." SWA440's flight crew acknowledged the instruction stating, "Position, and hold southwest four forty." At this time, AAR204 was 1.81 miles from the 24L runway threshold and the aircraft's altitude was 700 feet. According to the SWA440 Captain's statement, he turned onto taxiway V, which is perpendicular to runway 24L; he saw the Boeing 747 on final approach but believed the aircraft was landing on runway 24R.

The LC2 relief controller spent the next few seconds coordinating SWA440's southwesterly departure via the landline with the LAX local one (LC1) controller. At 2154:18, the LC2 relief controller stated, "Southwest four forty turn left heading two one zero runway two four left cleared for take off." The flight crew replied, "we'll turn two one zero cleared for takeoff runway two four left southwest four forty. AAR204 was 1.26 miles from the runway threshold and at 500 feet.

At 2154:26, the LC2 relief controller issued a wake turbulence advisory to the flight crew of UAL961, the lead aircraft on final approach to runway 24R and advised, "caution wake turbulence heavy seven forty seven short final." Radar data and recorded voice communications indicated UAL961 was not following any other aircraft to runway 24R. The wake turbulence advisory was in reference to AAR204 who was approximately 3 miles ahead of UAL961 but on final approach to runway 24L. The LC2 relief controller believed AAR204 was landing runway 24R, and therefore, a wake turbulence advisory would have been required.

At 2154:40, an aural and visual alert was generated by the Airport Movement Area Safety System (AMASS) at the LC2 position. AAR204 was .4 miles from the runway at 300 feet. At this time, recorded voice communications indicated the LC2 relief controller was issuing a landing clearance to Sky West 6040, the second aircraft on final approach to runway 24R. According to the Asiana captain's statement, he observed the Southwest B737 approaching runway 24L but believed the aircraft would hold short of the runway. Once he recognized the aircraft was entering the runway, he initiated a go-around and estimated it was about the time he was passing through 400 feet.

At 2154:48, a voice of unknown origin stated on the frequency, "is that four seven going around?" AAR204 was .18 miles from the runway at 200 feet.

At 2154:50, the LC2 relief controller advised the flight crew of SWA440, "cancel take off clearance hold in position." The flight crew responded by saying, "holding in position southwest four forty." The controller then instructed the flight crew of AAR204, "fly heading two five zero climb and maintain two thousand." The flight crew replied, "heading two five zero climb and maintain two thousand asiana two zero going around now." Radar data indicated AAR204 had flown over SWA440, clearing the aircraft by about 200 feet, and was now .32 miles past the runway threshold and climbing out of 500 feet.

At 2155:07, the flight crew of SWA440 advised the LC2 relief controller, "we're going to go to echo eight and come back southwest four forty." The LC2 relief controller approved the request and instructed the flight crew to taxi and hold short of runway 24L at the full length. Echo eight is a designated taxi way off of runway 24L.

At 2156:23, the flight crew of SWA440 asked the LC2 relief controller, "what happened up there sir." The controller replied, "well he apparently was lined up for the wrong runway." The flight crew responded by saying, "ok yeah the runways are so close together we looked at it and it was so big we thought he was on the right side as well." In response, the LC2 relief controller said, "yep, I did the exact same thing."

Upon hearing the AMASS alert, the operations supervisor who was located on the south side of the tower cab began walking to the north side of the tower cab, and saw AAR204 in a nose-high attitude, 200 to 300 feet above the runway. The aircraft appeared to be executing a go-around. The supervisor continued to the LC2 position, and began monitoring the actions of the LC2 relief controller. The operations supervisor looked at the DBRITE display and saw information indicating that AAR204 was assigned to land on runway 24L. He asked the LC2 relief controller if he knew AAR204 was landing on runway 24L. The controller responded, "I did not know he was on the left." The LC2 controller, who was leaving the tower cab, also heard the AMASS alert. He also began walking toward the LC2 position, observed AAR204 climbing in a go-around attitude, and saw SWA440 turning onto the runway below AAR204. The operations supervisor asked the LC2 controller if he had told the LC2 relief controller AAR204 was landing on the left side. The LC2 controller advised that he had done so, and that SWA440 had been awaiting a takeoff clearance on the concrete pad adjacent to the approach end of the runway. The LC2 controller asked if he should relieve the LC2 relief controller. The supervisor advised him to do so.

1.5 PERSONNEL INFORMATION

1.5.1 The LC2 Tower-Controller

The LC2 controller held an air traffic control tower operator certificate and a current medical certificate. He entered on duty with the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) on November 2, 1982. He was assigned to LAX in 2000, and received facility certification in 2002. Before his assignment to LAX, he previously worked at Kansas City Air Route Traffic Control Center (ARTCC), Los Angeles ARTCC, Los Angles TRACON, and Southern California TRACON (SCT). On the day of the incursion, he had been working the LC2 position for about 1 1/2 hours before the relief LC2 controller relieved him.

1.5.2 The LC2 Relief Tower-Controller

The FAA hired the LC2 relief controller as an air traffic controller in 1987. After completing his initial training at the FAA academy, the relief LC2 controller wa...