Accident Details
Probable Cause and Findings
The pilot’s failure to maintain airplane control following a reduction of thrust in the left engine during takeoff. The reason for the reduction in thrust could not be determined based on the available evidence.
Aircraft Information
Registered Owner (Historical)
Analysis
HISTORY OF FLIGHTOn August 20, 2020, about 1542 central daylight time, a Beech B200 airplane (marketed as a King Air 200), N198DM, was destroyed when it was involved in an accident near Rockford, Illinois. The private pilot was fatally injured. The airplane was operated as a Title 14 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) Part 91 positioning flight.
The purpose of the flight was to relocate the airplane to the pilot's home base at the DuPage Airport (DPA), West Chicago, Illinois. The airplane had been at Chronos Aviation, LLC (a 14 CFR Part 145 repair station), at the Rockford International Airport (RFD), Rockford, Illinois, for maintenance work.
Multiple airport-based cameras recorded the accident sequence. The videos showed the airplane taking off from runway 19. Shortly after liftoff, the airplane started turning left, and the airplane developed a large left bank angle as it was turning. The airplane departed the runway to the left and impacted the ground. During the impact sequence, an explosion occurred, and there was a postimpact fire. A video study estimated the airplane’s maximum groundspeed during the takeoff as 105.5 knots (kts).
Data recovered from an Appareo Stratus device onboard the airplane showed that about 1538, the airplane began taxing to runway 19. At 1540:34, the airplane crossed the hold short line for runway 19. At 1541:19, the airplane began a takeoff roll on runway 19. At 1541:42, the airplane began to depart the runway centerline to the left of the runway. Subsequent tracklog points showed the airplane gaining some altitude, and the tracklog terminated adjacent to a taxiway in a grassy area.
The Appareo Stratus data showed the airplane began to increase groundspeed on a true heading of roughly 185° about 1541. Airplane pitch began to increase at 1541:41 as the groundspeed reached about 104 kts. The groundspeed increased to 107 kts within the next 2 seconds, and the pitch angle reached around 4° nose-up at this time. In the next few seconds, pitch lowered to around 0° as the groundspeed decayed to around 98 kts. The pitch then became 15° nose-up as the groundspeed continued to decay to about 95 kts. A right roll occurred of about 13° and changed to a rapidly increasing left roll over the next 5 seconds. The left roll reached a maximum of about 86° left as the pitch angle increasingly became negative (the airplane nosed down). The pitch angle reached a maximum nose down condition of -73°. The data became invalid after 1541:53.4.
An airplane performance study based on the Appareo Stratus data showed that during the takeoff from runway 19, the airplane accelerated to a groundspeed of 98 kts and an airspeed of 105 kts before rotating and lifting off. The airplane pitched up, climbed, and gained height above the ground. Then, 4 seconds after rotation, the airplane began descending and slowing, consistent with a loss of power. A nose-left sideslip, a left side force, and a left roll were recorded, consistent with the loss or reduction in thrust of the left engine. The sideslip was reduced, likely due to opposite rudder input, and the airplane briefly rolled right. The airplane pitched up and was able to begin climbing again; however, it continued to lose speed. The sideslip then reversed, and the airplane rolled left again and impacted the ground.
One witness reported that he observed the accident sequence. He did not hear any abnormal engine noises, nor did he see any smoke or flames emit from the airplane before impact.
The airplane came to rest on a flat grass field to the east of runway 19 on airport property. The airplane sustained fire damage and was fragmented from impacting terrain. PERSONNEL INFORMATIONThe pilot established the King Air Academy in Phoenix, Arizona. The King Air Academy is a flight training facility that provides initial, recurrent, type rating, and simulator training for the King Air series of airplanes.
According to Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) records, the pilot did not hold a type rating for the accident airplane, nor was he required to hold one. AIRCRAFT INFORMATIONMaintenance Records
A review of the airplane’s maintenance records revealed no evidence of uncorrected mechanical discrepancies with the airframe, engines, or propellers. The recent maintenance work performed at Chronos Aviation, LLC, consisted of the installation of three new switches for the flaps, the installation of two auxiliary outboard fuel level senders, the adjustment of an ice vane door switch, work on a radar control data bus, and a patch repair to the left propeller de-ice boot.
Airplane Servicing
A fuel receipt showed that 304 gallons of Jet A fuel was purchased for the airplane at RFD on the day of the accident.
Airplane Systems
The airplane was certified for single-pilot operation. It was equipped with an autofeather system that was intended for use during takeoff and landing if there was a loss of engine power. The airplane was equipped with a rudder boost system, which was designed to reduce the required rudder pedal force in the event of an engine failure. The published minimum control airspeed (VMCA) was 86 kts.
The engine and propeller control levers on the accident airplane were located between the two cockpit seats. The power quadrant included two power levers (which controlled engine power from idle through takeoff) and two propeller levers (which controlled propeller speed and feathering) to the right of the power levers. When the power levers were lifted over the idle gate during ground operation, they controlled engine power and propeller blade angle through the ground fine and reverse ranges. Two engine condition levers were to the right of the propeller levers and had three positions: fuel cutoff, low idle, and high idle. The left condition lever controlled the left engine, and the right condition lever controlled the right engine.
Friction lock control knobs were located on the power quadrant. Each power lever had its own friction lock control knob at the base of the quadrant to adjust the power lever’s tension. One friction knob controlled the tension of both propeller levers. Turning the knobs counterclockwise increased tension and turning them clockwise reduced tension. The before engine starting checklist called for these friction locks to be set.
Weight and Balance
A review of the airplane’s weight and balance data showed that the airplane was within limitations for the accident flight. METEOROLOGICAL INFORMATIONThe estimated density altitude for the airport was 2,545 ft mean sea level. AIRPORT INFORMATIONMaintenance Records
A review of the airplane’s maintenance records revealed no evidence of uncorrected mechanical discrepancies with the airframe, engines, or propellers. The recent maintenance work performed at Chronos Aviation, LLC, consisted of the installation of three new switches for the flaps, the installation of two auxiliary outboard fuel level senders, the adjustment of an ice vane door switch, work on a radar control data bus, and a patch repair to the left propeller de-ice boot.
Airplane Servicing
A fuel receipt showed that 304 gallons of Jet A fuel was purchased for the airplane at RFD on the day of the accident.
Airplane Systems
The airplane was certified for single-pilot operation. It was equipped with an autofeather system that was intended for use during takeoff and landing if there was a loss of engine power. The airplane was equipped with a rudder boost system, which was designed to reduce the required rudder pedal force in the event of an engine failure. The published minimum control airspeed (VMCA) was 86 kts.
The engine and propeller control levers on the accident airplane were located between the two cockpit seats. The power quadrant included two power levers (which controlled engine power from idle through takeoff) and two propeller levers (which controlled propeller speed and feathering) to the right of the power levers. When the power levers were lifted over the idle gate during ground operation, they controlled engine power and propeller blade angle through the ground fine and reverse ranges. Two engine condition levers were to the right of the propeller levers and had three positions: fuel cutoff, low idle, and high idle. The left condition lever controlled the left engine, and the right condition lever controlled the right engine.
Friction lock control knobs were located on the power quadrant. Each power lever had its own friction lock control knob at the base of the quadrant to adjust the power lever’s tension. One friction knob controlled the tension of both propeller levers. Turning the knobs counterclockwise increased tension and turning them clockwise reduced tension. The before engine starting checklist called for these friction locks to be set.
Weight and Balance
A review of the airplane’s weight and balance data showed that the airplane was within limitations for the accident flight. WRECKAGE AND IMPACT INFORMATIONAll the major structural components of the airplane were located at the accident site. Flight control continuity was established for the airframe. The airplane’s fuel system was destroyed by the postimpact fire. All landing gear were found in the retracted position. The postimpact fire consumed most of the instrument and switch panels in the cockpit. The flap handle was found in the full up position; the rudder trim knob was found 4 units to the left; and the aileron trim knob was found 6 units to the right. The autofeather switch was found in the ARM position. The rudder boost switch (a gated switch) was found in the OFF position. The before engine starting checklist called for the rudder and aileron trim controls to be set and for the rudder boost switch to be in the ON position.
The power quadrant was destroyed by the impact sequence and the postimpact fire. When compared to an exemplar power quadrant, the throttle levers appeared to be full forward, and the propeller levers appeared to be forward of the fe...
Data Source
Data provided by the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB). For more information on this event, visit the NTSB Records Search website. NTSB# CEN20LA352